Discussion:
MSRAP questions
Erich Rickheit KSC
2005-02-16 22:01:42 UTC
Permalink
I'm looking at
http://homepages.tesco.net./~J.deBoynePollard/Proposals/IM2000/Architecture/msrap.html
If this isn't current, please correct me and ignore this message.

I'm only lightly familiar with ASN.1, so these might be misunderstandings
on my part; please correct me.

I don't see the definition of CommandQuerySize, nor do I see any
such command discussed in Architecture/msrap.html; nor a corresponding
response. Is this a typo, or a placeholder for a future extension?

In CommandRetrieve, I assume offset and length are in octets, and
the first octet is offset zero? This seems obvious to me, but I
think should be specified.

ResponseRetrieve just confuses me.

ResponseRetrieve ::= SEQUENCE {
data [0] IMPLICIT OCTET STRING
size [0] IMPLICIT INTEGER (0..MAX)
}

Shouldn't the size come first, so an app can allocate space
appropriately? And should they both say '[0]'?

Erich

Loading...